Skip to main content

Vikara

Vikara October 2024 Update – Is Silly Season Finally Here?

October 30, 2024 Vikara October 2024 Update – Is Silly Season Finally Here? DOWNLOAD PDF REPORT Happy Birthday Vikara! We ticked over two years this month. We want to thank all of our LPs, service providers and readers for the support. As Bitcoin teeters at its all-time high, we remain certain that our decision to build Vikara during the bear market was the right one.   We are excited to announce that our Australia feeder fund is ready for subscriptions. It allows Australian self-managed super funds to invest while lowering the minimum initial investment amount to A$25k. We look forward to you all rushing in at once. It is hard to be negative right now. The uncertainty caused by the US election will soon be behind us, China’s response to its economic problems will need to rise exponentially to stave off deflation, and the Federal Reserve’s easing cycle will accelerate as China’s problems reverberate globally.  China is a large concern, with the collapse of its money supply alarming. We do not believe the PBOC can control credit events, and think that the reaction to China’s stimulus, with hindsight, will look as foolish as when Bernanke said the 2007 subprime crisis was contained.  China’s deflation will turn into a tailwind for central banks globally and at the same time cause relief for the millions of people that are sick of prices going up. While we are yet to find out who is holding the proverbial bag, we believe digital assets will be a primary beneficiary of the unwind of centralized trust. Markets spent October questioning the Federal Reserve rate cuts, pushing the 10-year up 50bps after a couple of stronger than expected data points. We believe that the slowing in US labour markets and China’s issues are more likely result in the Fed accelerating its loosening policy than reversing it.  Adding to the concern around a second wave of inflation was the rising probability of a Trump presidency. We don’t buy Trump being inflationary. He was deflationary in his first term, as his tariffs were immediately offset by currency devaluations. His second term will be no different.  Since starting Vikara, we have battled against an adversarial SEC that has constantly created chaos for entrepreneurs trying to advance the utility of the internet. This may be about to change, with both political parties seemingly distancing themselves from Gensler.   If the macro landscape isn’t compelling enough, perhaps the seasonality into yearend is. The yearend risk-on rally is best expressed in digital assets. The moment we’ve been waiting for may be here.  Chart 1 – Bitcoin price seasonality (2012-2024)  Source: LSEG, Topdowncharts Macro An entire years’ worth of rate cut expectations was wiped out in October. This is the second time this year where such a large reversal in rate expectations has occurred. A data dependent Fed translates into a market that jumps at every data point that moves towards or away from inflation.  It has not been a normal start to the rate cutting cycle, after a small set of data has resulted in a rapid tightening in nominal rates. Chart 2 – 10-year UST yield around the first Fed rate cut (change in basis points) Source: @fwred Data dependence at the Fed is amplified by Trump’s election odds strengthening, with rate markets highlighting that investors believe America first policies will create a second wave of inflation. A pause in the direction of inflation pass-through doesn’t help sentiment (Chart 3). Chart 3 – Inflation pass-through / persistence (1950-2024) Source: @crossbordercap Adding to speculation of a second round of inflation was China’s decision to begin a stimulus program at the same time as the Fed’s easing cycle. The rush on Chinese equities is signalling that that the collapse of the largest real estate market in the world can be fixed with the stroke of a pen (Chart 4). We doubt it.  Chart 4 – China Home Prices YoY (2009-2024) Source: Bloomberg Finance L.P, @SoberLook China’s first round of stimulus will require the PBOC to expand its balance sheet exponentially to clean up the trillions of dollars of destroyed capital at the provincial level. This is starting to show up in the data as the PBOC’s balance sheet has risen by 9.4% in four months (Chart 5). Chart 5 – Central Bank Balance Sheets ($trillions) (2000-2025) Source: Refinitiv, Federal Reserve, PBoC, as of Sep 2024, @JeffWeniger Nationalizing its bankrupt state-owned enterprises and failed real estate developments will do little to change sentiment in China or stimulate demand. It will only highlight how weak its economy is and put US debt to GDP metrics back in line with its largest economic competitor (Chart 6). Chart 6 – US vs China net debt to GDP (2001-2024) Source: tradingview.com China’s net leverage has been underreported for years, using its provincial and state-owned enterprise balance sheets as an effective way to hide total leverage. That is all about to change. The pace with which M1 continues to collapse says all we need to know about the credit crisis (Chart 7).  Chart 7 – China M1 vs M2 (2001-2024) Source: @zerohedge The only way for China to avoid a deflationary spiral is to print an ungodly amount of new debt. We still question if this new debt creates inflation, as it may merely stop deflation. The collapse of China’s financial institution credit growth shows this isn’t a crisis that is easily fixed (Chart 8). Chart 8 – China Financial Institutions Loans YoY (2017-2024) Source: The Daily Shot, @SoberLook China’s PPI has fallen for 24 consecutive months, which will be hard to unwind with stimulus as its customers are moving offshore, leaving a large and underutilized manufacturing base (Chart 9).  Chart 9 – China PPI YoY (2006-2024) Source: Ollari Consulting This deflationary pressure is now showing up in Chinese CPI data (Chart 10), driven by weak consumer demand and abysmal sentiment. Western investors are forever questioning if the Fed is making a mistake, with 2008 as a recent memory. Chinese investors cannot speak out in the same way.

Vikara September 2024 Update – Tides Have Officially Turned

September 30, 2024 Vikara September 2024 Update – Tides Have Officially Turned DOWNLOAD PDF REPORT Gold knows all. It might come as a shock to many, but our learnings from our time investing in the analogue world translates well to the digital world. Rising gold prices unlock US dollar liquidity at global central banks, and this liquidity is set to drive an unprecedented rise in digital asset prices. Gold is the original Bitcoin. It is stable, durable, fungible, divisible and a hedge against monetary and fiscal irresponsibility. Gold derivative markets are many multiples larger than the underlying, meaning that every dollar increase has a substantial ripple effect on available liquidity. Chart 1 plots golds price in yellow (set forward by 12-months) against the combined market capitalization of digital assets (excluding BTC, ETH, and a few stable coins). It is a striking correlation isn’t it? Gold prices almost perfectly predict digital asset markets 12-months in advance. If gold is indeed the leading indicator, we are going to about to see a profoundly different digital asset market at this time next year. Are you prepared for Web3 to be a $4-trillion-dollar asset class? Wealth managers, superfunds and financial advisors need to debate this question. Chart 1 – Gold (fwd 12-months) versus digital asset market caps ex-(BTC, ETH, stables) (2019-2024) Source: Vikara Capital, TradingView.com As discussed in our macro section below, we do not see a recession. We see a myriad of idiosyncratic factors that are convoluting economic data. Election uncertainty passes. Inventories can’t be destocked forever. A world war is not the preferred path for anyone. Things can get better quickly. Inflation is behind us, monetary policy is becoming a tailwind, and the largest risk to global growth is not a western market for once. The supply chain hangover from Covid has abated and the fiscal setup across Western government is to outspend each other reshoring industry. It is a unique and wonderfully positive setup. The risks are short term in nature, and the market is fixated on them. The tailwinds are structural and unlikely to change regardless of which leaders are in place. It feels asymmetric to us even though this is fairly counter consensus right now. As we have said for most of the year, the time to be investing in digital asset is now. The space has only a few sophisticated competitors, the tokens have valuations that may never exist again, and we have been able to build a portfolio that we believe strongly that will perform well into the future. Macro While markets spent most of September flip flopping between a 25bps or 50bps cut, the Federal Reserve took the top end despite a split consensus. Taking a step back, the quantum is less important than the direction of travel, and the shift in global central bank policies is all that matters (Chart 2). Chart 2 – World Proportion of Central Banks Cutting Rates (1995-2025) Source: @MacroMicroMe, MAcvroBond Looser policy is driving a global liquidity rebound, which is now growing at an annualized rate of >6%, its fastest annual pace since April 2022 (Chart 3). The last time this chart printed a reading this high with an upwards trajectory was April 2020. Remember the good old days? Chart 3 – Global Monetary Liquidity (2010-2027) Source: @TomasOnMarkets The risk in the short term is if we have a hard landing or not. We continue to believe 2025 is a better year than 2024. While it is one data point, bankruptcy filings aren’t screaming recession (Chart 4). Chart 4 – Weekly Bancruptcy Filings (2006-2024) Source: Bloomberg, Apollo Chief Economist, @MikeZaccardi The market pricing in over 200bps of cuts at the start of this loosening cycle is already facilitating an economic rebound. This amount of easing is enormous compared to previous cycles (Chart 5). Chart 5 – Fed Rate Cuts Pricing at the Begining of Easing, Bp (1990-2024) Source: Adam Kurpiel, SocGen via John Authers, Bloomberg Bears believe that the difference between the 2-year treasury yield and the Fed funds dropping to -1.69%, the most in at least 35 years, is showing that a 2008 or 1989 style recession is close (Chart 6). Chart 6 – US 2-year – Fed Funds Rate (1989-2025) Source: Daily Chartbook, @KobeissiLetter Forward rate expectations also show a similarly dire outcome, with the 1-year versus 3-month rates pricing in 100bps of cuts in the next year, a differential that has never been this wide (Chart 7). Chart 7 – 1-Year vs 3-Month US Treasury Yield Curve (1962-2022) Source: Bloomberg L.P., Tradingview, @GameofTrades The above two charts give pause for concern, and while we believe the Fed is offsides, it has a lot of room to move. Looking at CPI and core CPI, updated for real time shelter metrics, the Fed can lower rates 200bps and still be above inflation (Chart 8). Chart 8 – Headline Inflation Adjusted For Alternative Shelter Metrics (2018-2024) Source: WisdomTree, @JeremyDSchwartz This cycle is very different from 2008 and 1989. Covid was a supply side shock, with supply chains normalizing. We are close to the end of the inventory destocking, the US election is nearly over, and geopolitical tensions are precarious but stable. Today’s uncertainty is an opportunity (Chart 9). Chart 9 – Market Now Sees Odds of Recession by June as 50/50 (Jul-Sep 2024) Source: Simon White – Bloomberg via Macrobond Our optimism comes from several areas. Firstly, US labour market weakness is clouded by immigration. As an example, the Sahm Rule, which when triggered has historically led to a recession, does not signal a recession when looking at prime age nonemployment rates (Chart 10). Chart 10 – Sahm rule recession indicator (1960-2020) Source: Oxford Economics, Haver Analytics, TheDailyShot Second, credit spreads are not signalling worry (Chart 11). Either the entire high yield market is out to lunch, or the risk of a credit event in the near term remains low.  Chart 11 – US Bloomberg Barclays High Yield Index (2012-2025) Source: Bloomberg, @biancoresearch Third, lower rates are going to

Vikara August 2024 Update – Volatility, Sentiment, and Digital Asset Resilience

August 31, 2024 Vikara August 2024 Update – Volatility, Sentiment, and Digital Asset Resilience August was volatile to say the least. The VIX roundtripped from 16 to 65 and back again, the DXY collapsed 3% to levels not seen since mid-2023, gold rallied to ATH’s above 2,500/oz, the S&P500 rose 2%, and for a moment people were convinced the BOJ destroyed markets with a 20bp rate hike. All of this was wrapped in a bow of escalating tensions in the middle east. Digital assets were not spared from the volatility, and the range bound chop sideways has had a material negative impact on sentiment. While it is tempting to hold on to the continued call for the incoming banana zone, the average retail punter is fatigued and tuning out. We like the setup from here. Markets never behave how consensus believes they should. The chorus all year has been ETF -> BTC halving -> Fed cuts -> ATH. Most of those waiting for the rally are bruised, broken, and despondent. Nearly all our sentiment indicators are at the lows. Whether it is social media engagement, fear and greed indicators, or the alt coin speculation index, all are showing that people are checked out (Chart 1). Volumes and liquidity across the space are declining while stable coin holdings rise. Chart 1 – Speculation Index (2018-2024) Source: Capriole Investment, @TheDeFinvestor The crypto market is finally in a place where consensus isn’t up, positioning is neutral to negative, interest levels are minimal, and liquidity is low. The average investor has returned to equity markets to chase Nvidia and is comforting themselves with that thought that equity market returns are good enough. It is hard to argue with this logic. The ETFs have entrapped tens of billions of dollars of demand that will now not enter digital asset markets but sit in centralized products at the largest financial institutions. These ETFs give the average person exposure without needing to learn anything about the space. This is the beauty of what Vikara is investing in. We own a portfolio of tokens that we believe are software solutions that will become critical infrastructure of the future digital economy. During these periods of sideways chop, we are comforted that these teams continue to build and grow as evidenced by user growth. While we generally try to refrain from discussing specific tokens in our write-ups as we are not in the business of pumping our book, we are encouraged by advancements this month of partnerships with major US universities, granted patents for off-chain cloud compute innovation, and soaring real world asset growth. Digital assets, and their applications are evolving rapidly, despite many of these advancements being lost in the volatility and memecoin craziness. In volatile times, we remain focused on the fundamental value drivers of these ecosystems to ensure we are well placed when prices turn. Macro The macro continues to evolve towards a supportive monetary backdrop. The continued weakness in employment data has been significant enough for the Fed to communicate its job is done. Figure 1 – Jerome Powell talking at Jackson Hole Source: Federalreserve.gov Powell was unequivocally dovish and market expectations for several rate cuts is now consensus. The only ambiguity about coming rate cuts is how many and by how much. Chart 2 – Implied Federal Fund Rate Based on 30-Day Futures (2024) Source: LSEG Datastream and @ Yardeni Research US inflation is back in an acceptable range for looser monetary policy, and its downward bias due to delayed rental data is a tailwind for the Federal Reserve. Core CPI shows that disinflation is now ingrained in the US (Chart 3). Chart 3 – Core inflation (YoY%) (2015-2024) Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Depending on what items you put in core CPI (sticky versus flexible), the US is experiencing deflation in some categories (Chart 4). This may drive the Federal Reserve to act faster as the only thing worse than inflation in an over levered economy is deflation. Chart 4 – Atlanta Fed flexible price core CPI (YoY%) (2008-2024) Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Market-based inflation expectations (5-year breakeven) moved down to 1.89% last week, the lowest level since December 2020 (Chart 5). Chart 5 – US Inflation Expectations 5 Year US Breakeven Inflation Rate (%)  Source: Charlie Bilello At the same time, the Bureau of Labor Statistics showed that a whopping 818,000 fewer jobs have been created in the year prior to March 2024 than originally estimated (Chart 6). Chart 6 – US Payrolls Growth (2006-2024) Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Matt Stiles The same people that are telling us that the US is in good shape are also the ones missing their forecasts by multiple standard deviations. This is why the rapid increase in unemployment is concerning for policy makers (Chart 7). Chart 7 – United States Unemployment Rate (2024) Source: Amanda from CML Pro Job openings per unemployed person are now back to pre-COVID levels, with rate of decline adding to the concerns that the Fed is behind the curve (Chart 8). Chart 8 – Job openings per unemployed person (2001-2021) Source:  BofA Global Research, Bloomberg, @MikeZaccardi It is not surprising that the market moved to price in at least three cuts for the year, and it is now consensus that the Fed needs to act quickly to stave off a much more serious recession (Chart 9). Chart 9 – Implied Probabilities for Policy in 2024 (2023-2024) Source: Convera, Macrobond, @MacroKova Interest rate futures are pricing in eight Fed rate cuts over the next 12-months, the most since the 2008 Global Financial Crisis (GFC) (Chart 10). Over the last 60 years, every time the market expected 200 basis points of rate cuts, a recession in the US followed within several months. Chart 10 – 12-month forward market-implied change in Fed funds rate (1963-2023) Source: Golman Sachs, @KobeissiLetter While rate markets are concerned about a recession, US High Yield credit spreads are not, remaining near their tightest levels since

Vikara July 2024 Update – All systems go for crypto’s mission to the Moon!

July 31, 2024 Vikara July 2024 Update – All systems go for crypto’s mission to the Moon! Between Trump’s assassination attempt, an inventory destocking cycle, job market weakness, accelerating disinflation, and a Federal Reserve that is offsides, we haven’t seen such an asymmetric setup since we launched Vikara. What a time to be investing in digital assets. We spent most of July trying to ignore the many micro distractions that pale in comparison to what is taking place at a macro level. The Ethereum ETF is a distraction, the US election is a distraction, the halving is a distraction. While these are incremental positives, we suggest investors zoom out. The Fed is about to pivot. It has all the data it needs to claim victory on inflation, we expect it to lay the groundwork this week for a 50bp cut in September. This will allow the PBOC and ECB to ease, while the BOJ slow walks its way out of a decade of ultra loose monetary policy at the wrong time. Chart 1 shows commodity markets believe US rates should be >3% lower given current economic demand. The divergence since mid-2020 is a function of the Federal Reserve policy mistakes during and after Covid which have now run their course. The question is if another mistake is made. Chart 1 – US 10-year yields (candle) versus LME metals index relative to gold (orange) (2009-2024) Source: Tradingview.com For this reason, we believe the Fed lowers rates faster than the market expects. The consequence of incorrectly delaying an easing cycle has far worse implications on the downside than it did when it mistakenly waited to see if inflation was sticky on the upside. We are entering a period of loose fiscal and monetary policy, with a US economy that avoids a recession, and a firming regulatory backdrop for the digital assets. If we are right, the digital asset bull market is yet to begin despite BTC near all-time highs. While Fed easing cycles will push many investors into traditional asset classes like real estate or bonds, the potential returns from a well-constructed digital asset portfolio are considerably higher in our view. As a minimum, an allocation into digital assets will complement a diversified portfolio. Our portfolio of digital assets gives our LPs tier one exposure to the space. We have completed rigorous due diligence on every token we own and it is well placed to capitalize on the significant asymmetry that markets have created. Now is the time to allocate into digital assets. Macro The final inning of an inventory destocking cycle always lasts for enough time to force central banks to pivot. With many geopolitical risks impacting supply chains, as well as most of the western world being at the ballot box in 2024, is it any wonder that businesses keep destocking (Chart 2). Chart 2 – S&P500 days of sales of inventory (1997-2024) Source: BofA Global Research, FactSet Inventory destocking cycles convince the best economists that growth is faltering. We will never forget hearing a CEO of a major steel distributor say that “the entire industry held its breath” into the end of the destock in late 2015. Copper prices tell us all we need to know (Chart 3). Chart 3 – Copper prices (LTM) Source: Tradingview.com As nominal growth is impacted by destocking, real growth appears to undershoot and forces policy makers to pivot. The Federal Reserve is offsides right now, with ISM new orders showing us how quickly the destocking has accelerated (Chart 4). Chart 4 – US ISM services PMI (2010-2024) Source: Ollari Consulting Small business hiring plans have been weakening for months, often seen as a leading indicator for US unemployment (Chart 5). The trend is anything but supportive of a >5% Fed funds rate. Chart 5 – Small business hiring plans versus US unemployment (1985-2024)  Source: Gravekal Research, Macrobond, @MichaelAArouet  The decrease in full-time jobs has reached 1.55 million year over year (Chart 6), with the overall weakness in employment markets being hidden by the creation of short-term employment opportunities. Chart 6 – YoY change in full time works (1969-2024) Source: Refinitiv, BLS, DOL, @jeffweniger As employment data continues to be revised lower, the weakness is starting to show up in US unemployment (Chart 7), which has moved to its highest level since November 2021. Chart 7 – U.S Unemployment Rate (%) (1948-2023)  Source: Charlie Bilello The unemployment rate is climbing as payroll growth is slowing (Chart 8), changing the calculus for the Fed. We expect the Fed to communicate a need to ease in the near term, opting to act sooner (despite the election cycle) to avoid another policy mistake. Chart 8 – Civilian unemployment rate versus nonfarm payrolls (2022-2024)   Source:  Bureau of Labor Statistics/Haver Analytics, @RenMacLLC A slowing labour market is creating wage disinflation in the service industry, with the quit rate for those working in accommodation and food services falling to a fresh cycle low (Chart 9). Chart 9 – Accomodation and food service wages versus JOLTS quit rate (2005-2025) Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Haver Analytics, @RenMacLLC  Wages, the labour market, and core PCE inflation are now all slowing in unison (Chart 10). Chart 10 – US Core PCE Price Index MoM (2016-2024) Source: TheDailyShot Broad based disinflation is supportive of the Fed being accommodative (Chart 11), with more than half of 74 US CPI components running below 2.0% YoY (the first time since 2020). Chart 11 – Proportion of US CPI component above 2% YoY based on 74 components (2010-2024) Source: BofA Global Research, BLS, Haver, @MikeZaccardi In addition, nearly 70% of US CPI components are no longer rising >0.2% on a MoM basis (Chart 12). Chart 12 – % of US CPI Components Rising >0.2% MoM (2010-2024) Source: @VrntPerception The substantially lagging rental component of CPI, which makes up over 30% of the index, has accelerated lower (Chart 13). Chart 13 – Rent of primary resident and owners’ equivalent rent (2018-2024) Source: Council of Economic Advisors, Zillow; Bureau of

Vikara June 2024 Update – The Unseen Revolution that is Happening Now

June 30, 2024 Vikara June 2024 Update – The Unseen Revolution that is Happening Now Chart 1 is fascinating. It shows the considerable time, energy and brain power needed to launch the Bitcoin network. Satoshi’s invention leveraged decades of iteration and prior knowledge into what is one of the most successful digital networks ever invented. The digital asset ecosystem continues to build upon its foundation, leveraging research, open-source code and shared data. Millions of people globally are focused on improving digital infrastructure. Chart 1 is a sanity check for those that believe digital assets are going away. Chart 1 – Evolution leading to BTC’s launch Source: @BitcoinMagazine While many Web3 businesses do a poor job articulating it to investors, many teams are quietly executing business plans to advance use cases. As it was with Bitcoin, it goes unseen by the majority, particularly given these innovations are not happening inside listed equities. Wall Street is willing to push Nvidia to astronomical levels on the back of the need for an unlimited global data centre build out without taking the time to think about the technology that is going to provide provenance for the data being processed. Do we really believe that global corporates are going pay for the privilege to transfer their intellectual property into large language models that are specifically designed to replace the businesses using them? At what point does data provenance become critical these businesses? Perhaps a better question is how many will opt in to pay big tech for a provenance solution when it is big tech that is commoditizing and selling others data? The opportunity for Web3 in data provenance alone is massive, given it can mitigate this risk for a fraction of the cost of big tech. Any business with data (client lists, algorithms, process manuals, research, images, working plans, asset reconciliations, etc), should be discussing this risk today. Bitcoin’s value is in the ~1.5 megabytes of data it processes every ten minutes to provide provenance for 21 million coins. Web3 can provide provenance on all types of metadata attached to real world intellectual property. Macro Equity managers remain unambiguously positive, with Bank of America’s global fund manager survey showing cash levels down to 4% (the lowest levels since June 2021) (Chart 2). Chart 2 – Fund manager cash levels (1999-2024) Source: BoFa Global Research This sentiment hasn’t flowed through to any other asset class, with a bearish month for digital assets, commodities, and real estate. While equity markets keep pushing higher, only 30% of stocks inside the S&P500 are outperforming the index (Chart 3). Chart 3 – Percentage of stocks that outperformed the S&P500 index (1990-2024) Source: Richard Bernsten Advisors LLC, BofAML US Strategy, @Kobeissiletter The dispersion in equities is more obvious when looking at the NASDAQ, with NVDA alone contributing to 40% of the total returns for the index year to date. This is anything but a broad-based rally (Chart 4). Chart 4 – Nvidia versus the rest of the NASDAQ market share gain (2024) Source: Kelvin Mu from Translink Capital Despite the low breadth in the equity market, global fund managers are the most bullish since November 2021, which combines expectations around growth, cash levels and equity allocations (Chart 5). Chart 5 – BoFA global fund manager survey rank of growth, cash, equity allocations (2001-2024) Source: BoFA global research Fund managers and CEOs are increasingly on the same page, with positive sentiment returning to the business leaders that are seeing demand in real time (Chart 6). Chart 6 – CEO confidence levels (1985-2024) Source: Conference Board, Goldman Sachs Investment Research, @mikezaccardi Confidence seems to come from business leaders and investors gearing up for another Trump presidency, which is expected to be positive for rates and markets. Punters believe Biden’s chance of re-election are low and falling (Chart 7). Chart 7 – Presidential forecast over time (2024) Source: @Polymarket There is a notable disagreement between the optimism CEO’s and asset managers have versus Main Street. Some say it is because Biden’s “strong economy and jobs market” is skewed because it is based on over new 2 million government jobs since he took office (Chart 8). Chart 8 – US government employees (2020-2024) Source: Fred.com As government roles keep rising, downward revisions of 2023 Main Street jobs data continues, confirming that the data was overestimated by more than 770,000 jobs. This implies that about one in four jobs that were reported to be added in 2023 never existed. No wonder voters aren’t feeling it. Add to this the continued decline in full time roles, which fell by 625,000 in May (Chart 9), the biggest drop in full-time employment since December 2023, which also came with a rise in unemployment to 4%. Chart 9 – Employed, usually work full time (1970-2024) Source: FRED.com Part time employment is the only strong area of the labor market, and while Chart 10’s axis is misleading, seeing foreign born workers gaining six million jobs while native born workers lose one to two million since Biden too office isn’t helping Biden’s loose immigration policy (Chart 10). Chart 10 – US foreign versus native born workers (2015-2024) Source: US Bureau of Labor statistics, Financial Times Sadly, even the part-time employment market strength seems to be coming to an end, with temporary help service jobs back below pre-Covid levels (typically seen as a leading indicator) (Chart 11). Chart 11 – All employees, temporary help services (1990-2024) Source: US Bureau of Labor Statistics, National Bureau of Economic Research, Game of Trades Another way to measure how Main Streeters are feeling about the economy is The University of Michigan’s Current Conditions Index minus the University of Michigan’s Expectations Index, which has just hit a new low. It is notable that all past bottoms have coincided with recessions (Chart 12). Chart 12 – The University of Michigan’s Current Conditions minus Expectations Index (1978-2024) Source: Ollari Consulting, Bloomberg It is no surprise that sentiment is this bad given the data across the economy. Starting with

Vikara May 2024 Update – Bipartisan Support – Banana Zone Incoming!

May 31, 2024 Vikara May 2024 Update: Bipartisan Support – Banana Zone Incoming! Digital assets becoming a 2024 US election issue will be viewed in hindsight as the final hurdle that ushered in large scale global adoption. Trump turned positive, Biden pivoted, and a politically charged SEC has been left hanging out to dry. We finally have bipartisan agreements to define a regulatory framework, the Bitcoin ETFs prove Wall Street has an insatiable demand for the asset class, and the global monetary and fiscal liquidity cycle is turning at the same time as the halving. What is coming next is a generational opportunity. When regulation is defined, the inflows of capital into digital assets will be enormous. Entrepreneurs will partner with the US and begin solving its digital infrastructure inefficiencies. A fly wheel will start and it will usher in the acceptance of the digital asset opportunity. This is really clear for those of us watching closely, despite the headlines doing little justice to the pace of innovation. As political objectives change, the message from the media and industry will too, and we will be fielding questions on real world use cases instead of meme momentum or SEC cases. Despite Bitcoin being at all-time highs, the opportunity to invest is now, just as it was in the last cycle, and the cycle before that. With all the tailwinds mentioned above and below, it is difficult to make a case that the digital asset prices are lower at year end. US M2 growth has turned positive (Chart 1), fiscal spending remains loose, interest rates have stopped rising, Fed bailouts have restarted, and US growth is slowing. All of this bodes well for more progress on inflation, despite it looking increasingly like a necessary evil along the way to a deglobalized world. Chart 1 – Global M2 money supply (logarithmic) (2008-2024) Source: @TomasOnMarkets Macro Parsing out signal versus noise is the hardest part about the seemingly unlimited set of macro data points per month. Understanding the net amount of liquidity is what we are trying to determine at any given point. The one thing we are certain of, is that more liquidity is now required. China’s contracting M1 money supply is very concerning to us. How bad must its economy be for physical currency and coins, demand deposits, traveller’s checks, and other checkable deposits to be shrinking (Chart 2)? Chart 2 – China M1 Money Supply (2000-2024) Source: Ollari Consulting China focused financial analysts are now pricing in the negative bias of the state of the economy, with 12-month forward earnings for the CSI 300 Index declining all year (Chart 3). Chart 3 – Chinese 12-month forward consensus earnings (CSI300, weekly) (2011-2024) Source: Longview Economics, Macrobond, thedailyshot.com China’s real estate crisis also continues to worsen. Chinese home prices dropped by 0.9% in April, the second-biggest decline on record. Home prices have declined in 30 of the last 33 months. China’s housing market recession has worsened after nearly three years (Chart 4). Chart 4 – Chinese home prices (2011-2024) Source: True Insights, investing.com, @jsblokland Markets have been expecting monetary easing from China for some time, and while it has stepped up efforts recently, its actions continue to fall short. Local government asset purchases, small cuts to borrowing rates and minimum deposit changes are not enough (Chart 5). Chart 5 – Chinese property prices versus monetary policy rate (2005-2024) Source: Topdown Charts, LSEG, NBS The lack of support from the top is creating fear, with the pace at which Chinese people are withdrawing their money from the banking system becoming concerning. Record withdrawals are a sign that the pressure we have been talking about all year is becoming serious onshore (Chart 6). Chart 6 – Chinese new monthly Yuan deposits (Trillions of Yuan) (2000-2024) Source: Bloomberg While we will never know where this cash is being deployed, we suspect that Chinese private sector gold demand has a lot to do with it, with 543 tonnes imported into China in 1Q24 with only 35% of that making its way to the PBoC (Chart 7). Chart 7 – Est. Quarterly PBOC gold purchases (mt) (2006-2024) Source: World Gold Council, Gainsville Coins, IMF, BIS China needs a joint and substantial monetary and fiscal easing. However,  the repricing of Japanese interest rates means that any interest rate declines in China will add weight to an already heightened risk of a currency devaluation (Chart 8). Chart 8 – Japanese 10-year government bond yields (2006-2024) Source: TradingView Maintaining its currency remains incredibly important for China, particularly given the Yuan’s share of cross-border trade. After decades of convincing the world that its currency can be relied upon, a sudden devaluation would be disastrous (Chart 9). Chart 9 – Cross-border FX deals by currency (2010-2024) Source: @StubbornFacts Higher ex-Chinese interest rates limit the ability for Beijing to stimulate. Strategically, it is no surprise that the US may want to maintain higher rates for longer as an effective form of pressure on China. As a result, markets are finally questioning rate cuts in 2024 (Chart 10). Chart 10 – Market pricing for the Fed funds rate change in 2024 (2023-2024) Source: Thedailyshot.com But how can the US afford to maintain higher rates without causing issues to its economy? It cannot. The Fed merely took risk onto its balance sheet when the banking sector collapsed in 2023. The level of support still being provided is significant (Chart 11). Chart 11 – Credit facilities provided by the Federal reserve (2003-2024) Source: Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (US) While the support provided to bank balance sheets has worked to date, there are more signs that the US economy is starting to slow, with the Citi US economic surprise index now considerably below zero (Chart 12). Chart 12 – Citi US Economic Surprise Index (2021-2024) Source: Citi, TheDailyShot.com Other leading indicators are also pointing to potential concerns, with the US Conference Board Leading Economic Index down 13.1% from its peak (Chart 13). Chart

Vikara April 2024 Update – Welcome to your Orwellian future

April 30, 2024 Vikara April 2024 Update: Welcome to your Orwellian future We have decided not to publish our investor update in April because Australia’s eSafety commission has clearly articulated that any content that is not supported by the Australian Government will not be tolerated and there will be consequences for non-compliance. We have no choice but to comply. While we can joke about it now, freedom of speech is being curtailed. The US FISA and Australian governments eSafety commission enables unelected government employees to pry through your computer, its files, and any online services you use without your permission or a search warrant. You may think that you are boring, and your data is not what the government is looking for, but it is. Arguing that you don’t care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don’t care about free speech because you have nothing to say. It saddens us that kids will never know a world where privacy is a basic human right. Between the surveillance cameras on every corner, to the legalization of total transparency on the internet, privacy and free speech are sacrifices the majority still seem happy to compromise on. Collecting data on every citizen has so many potential negative destinations. It is not that we believe the governments intend to use this data for evil, it is just that they are building the infrastructure that can entrap us all without laying out the governance structures needed to ensure it will not. Is it any surprise that digital assets are technology non grata? The argument that these rules are required for safety is a joke. The government does not need to access photos of my family on my hard drive to keep me safe. Yet, they are now allowed to without a warrant. What is still misunderstood within digital assets is that Bitcoin is only half of the story. It is designed to help create financial sovereignty, while Web3 is all about creating digital sovereignty. While these two may seem different, you cant have one without the other. You may have a sovereign asset to use, but if your internet connection is linked to your government ID and your central bank digital currency, will you be able to use your Bitcoin? It may seem far fetched, but this has been proposed in Australia, the US, Canada and the UK in the past month. Figure 1 – Trust us, what could possibly go wrong?  Source: The New York Times Macro It is worth starting our macro commentary with a simple image of the four pages that define the longest running democracy that the world has ever seen: The US constitution (Figure 2). Figure 2 – The US Constitution Source: Unknown Almost every aspect of it talks to the specific rights, freedoms and obligations that the government needs to afford its citizens. It is written with the backdrop that governance of people is a privelage, not a right. Compare this to the 185,000 pages in the Code of Federal Regulations today. Compare this to the internet, which is one of the largest economies in the world, with its constitution dictated by unelected officials outside of the view of the public. It is illegal for them to open your physical mail, but legal to read every email you send and receive. The amount of US Treasuries that “the internet” now holds is greater than many of the largest countries in the world. This is expected to grow exponentially in the short term, as the tokenization of real world assets enables ownership of any asset (Chart 1). Chart 1 – Holdings of US treasuries Source: DeFiLama, US Department of Treasury While many internet users remain unaware as its rules of engagement are being shaped outside of the view of the public eye, it is obvious that government overreach will accelerate until people resist. Sadly, the number of people resisting the totalitarian rules being enforced remains small. This leads us to the Bitcoin halving, which happened this month. Its supply is now only increasing at one percent per annum for the next four years (Chart 2). This is in the context of the number of users on the internet that is still rising >1.5% per year even after 34 years of growth. Chart 2 – Annualized supply issuance of Bitcoin (2011-2024) Source: Deutsche Bank, Hashlabs, TheDailyShot There is an ever increasing demand with falling supply. At the same time, governments are destroying people’s purchasing power in real time as reckless monetary policy is seen for what it is. Gold prices in Japanese Yen show this. Holding yen is a quick path to ruin (Chart 3). Chart 3 – Japanese Yen in Gold terms (2000-2024) Source: Tradingview What is happening in Japan today is no different to what happened in Zimbabwe in the early 2000s. The only difference is scale of the y-axis in chart 4. Just because Japan is a larger economy, doesn’t mean it wont suffer the same fate. Chart 4 – Zimbabwe Dollar versus the US exchange rate (2001-2009) Source: David Greguska While it feels more stable for those holding US dollars, Euros, or British pounds, this too is a relative façade due to inflation eroding purchasing power over the past three years. At the end of the day, purchasing power in all fiat currencies is eroding, some faster than others (Chart 5). Chart 5 – Inflation across major economies (YoY%) (2020-2024) Source: US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Eurostat, UK Office for National Statistics, S&P Global The Big Mac Index shows the erosion of purchasing power. Interestingly, the Big Mac Index and US house prices have both risen ~2.5x since the year 2000, but that’s because both are move valuable today instead of the purchasing power of the dollar declining. Right? Chart 6 – Big mac index versus US CPI (2012-2023) Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, The Economist, US Bureau of Labor Statistics (via Haver

Vikara March 2024 Update – Heading towards a digital future

March 31, 2024 Vikara March 2024 Update: Heading towards a digital future To access the full article, please download the PDF Download PDF If it isn’t already apparent, we are heading towards a digital future. Digital identities, digital wallets, digital social scores, and digital control. It is no longer up for debate. Global governments are seizing the opportunity to link every fundamental human right to a centralized digital system. These rights may include access to healthcare, a bank account, your identity, the right to vote, to run a company, or to drive on taxpayer roads. How can we expect to exercise free speech when an “off” switch can be flicked if one has an opposing view? Figure 1 – This is the infrastructure we are currently being forced into. Source: blog.digitalasset.com, Vikara Capital This month, Australia’s senate voted to adopt a digital identity with no opportunity for debate, the SWIFT network announced it is developing infrastructure for cross border central bank digital currencies, and the European Council formerly adopted European digital identity wallets. This centralized system, which will be linked across all western governments, has an extremely high likelihood of being corrupted due to the degree in which it will concentrate power and control in the hands of a few. Governments want to own, operate, sensor, and regulate your access to their society. While digital ID’s are being pushed under the guise of convenience, the ultimate goal is to connect everything you say on-and-offline to a central bank digital currency, which will transfer your basic human rights to movement, speech, and assembly, to an unelected committee. The infrastructure being installed today has the potential to oppress every human being. The leaders promising that it is in our “best interest”, will inevitably be replaced by different faces and agendas. We will no longer be talking about mis-or-dis-information. There will be one source of information: the government. Everything else will be irrational waffle that does not fit into the world view we are allowed to align with. It sounds draconian but the systems being installed today have the potential to create such a world. We suggest thinking about the tail risk of government-imposed constraints. Research decentralized systems and understand the value of self-custody. Understand what the alternatives are and why having them is important. We regularly talk about this with our LPs. The infrastructure being built in digital assets right now is the alternative to centralized and autocratic control. Vikara is investing in the platforms of the future that will allow many around the world to an alternative to centralized systems. To access the full article, please download the PDF. Download PDF Be the First to KnowKeep up to date with industry news and events   ©

Vikara February 2024 Update – The Time to Invest in Digital Assets is Now!

March 1, 2024 Vikara February 2024 Update: The Time to Invest in Digital Assets is Now! To access the full report, please download the PDF Download PDF FOMO is always required for investors to jump into an emerging market. Bitcoin has made fresh relative all-time highs versus the US 30-year bond, the Russell 2000, and it is knocking on the door relative to the S&P500 and NASDAQ. It is also close to its absolute all-time high. A portfolio without digital asset exposure is fast becoming an underperforming one. Digital assets capture the return streams of novel business models and the demand from high net worths, family offices and institutions via the new launched spot ETFs is a first step towards a shift in capital flows. The game theory of digital assets is structured for early adopters to be rewarded the most. Digital scarcity is real and an ever-expanding monetary system is fuelling adoption. As we’ve repeated – infinite fiat supply is meeting finite token supply. Sadly, much of the outperformance will have been earned by few by the time most realise the potential. We are 23-months into the fastest tightening cycle in history and what many believed was a rate sensitive, long duration asset class, is teetering on new highs. We continue to ask investors the same question we have been asking since we launched: what are you waiting for? Vikara launched in October 2022 and it felt like the worst possible time. Hindsight is 20:20 (Chart 1). Many continue to claim they don’t understand the space, that there are better returns elsewhere, or that digital assets won’t be around long-term. In the last cycle, the ex-Bitcoin and Ethereum market capitalization rose 27x in 22-months. This opportunity doesn’t exist elsewhere. The next iteration of the digital economy is being built and adopted in real time. We are front row investors into what will be foundational infrastructure running global commerce. Just as Apple was to Blackberry and Netflix to Blockbuster, Web3 will be to Web2. As an example, Uniswap (the largest decentralized exchange) proposed this week that wants to start charging fees for its services. If approved, it would have a price to earnings ratio overnight. Uniswap captured its audience, built its service, and will now monetize its work. Sounds like Web2 right? Uniswap has had $1.8 trillion in cumulative traded volumes in four years, earning $3.3bn in fees. With average monthly volumes of >$40bn, even a 0.2% fee would see ~$1 billion in fees sent to holders, translating to a ~10x price to earnings ratio. This is remarkably cheap given its growth potential. Understanding digital assets and investing in the space is an all-encompassing task. The opportunities are incredible and the pace is exponential. We built Vikara because we knew many would want exposure and needed a trusted partner to do this work for them. We have spent the three years conducting due diligence on hundreds of tokens so that our portfolio is ready to capture this opportunity. We are ready. We hope you are too. To access the full report, please download the PDF. Download PDF Be the First to KnowKeep up to date with industry news and events   ©

Vikara January 2024 Update – From Government Debts to Digital Assets

February 1, 2024 Vikara January 2024 Update: From Government Debts to Digital Assets To access the full article, please download the PDF Download PDF As global government debts surge, our confidence in digital assets grows stronger. The realization that governments worldwide continuously print fiat currency, reminiscent of single-ply toilet paper, underscores the urgency for alternative financial solutions. From wars to pandemics, the cyclical pattern of inducing panic, followed by currency printing, perpetuates. This erosion of trust fuels the demand for self-custody solutions. Examining Chart 1, we discern why stock markets remain buoyed by government and central bank interventions. The wealthiest individuals accumulate substantial gains, shielded by governmental support, rendering the cost of selling far higher than enduring a recession. While data on the digital asset ecosystem’s distribution among the top 10% is scarce, its anticipated scarcity against the declining USD bolsters its value. With the advent of easily accessible ETFs, capital inflow into this asset class surges. The potential transition from a 0.5% to a 5% allocation among the elite underscores a significant paradigm shift. The recent ETF launch witnessed minute-by-minute speculation, highlighting the growing interest in digital assets. Yet, every Bitcoin added to an ETF diminishes its availability for sovereign nations and forward-thinking individuals. The imperative of self-custody becomes increasingly apparent as governments encroach to manage debts. Institutional acknowledgment of tokenization’s benefits signals a significant market shift. The impending Web3 era promises a 24-hour capital market, redefining asset valuation dynamics. Despite macroeconomic uncertainties, the Federal Reserve’s potential rate cuts loom. Inflationary concerns persist, albeit tempered by stabilizing economic indicators. Transitioning to digital assets presents multifaceted opportunities. The recent SEC approval of spot Bitcoin ETFs signifies a landmark moment, reshaping institutional investment landscapes. The convergence of traditional finance with digital assets heralds a transformative era. Institutional endorsements and increased regulatory clarity pave the way for broader market adoption. As digital asset ownership diversifies and institutional inflows surge, the crypto ecosystem’s liquidity expands. The upcoming BTC halving and favorable regulatory environment underscore positive market sentiment. Institutional endorsement coupled with growing user adoption portends a bullish outlook for the crypto market. Despite regulatory uncertainties, the momentum towards mainstream acceptance is palpable. In conclusion, navigating economic trends entails embracing digital assets as viable alternatives amidst global financial uncertainties. The convergence of traditional finance with emerging technologies heralds a new era of financial sovereignty and opportunity. To access the full report, please download the PDF. Download PDF Be the First to KnowKeep up to date with industry news and events   ©